blog post | marketing

A/B/n testing vs A/B testing: Pros and cons of multivariate testing on a website

Jarret Fleagle Team Photo
Jarrett FleagleDirector of Business Development

In the digital world, the design, layout, and content of your website can greatly influence user behavior and conversion rates. But how do you decide which version of a webpage resonates most with your audience? The answer lies in A/B testing and multivariate A/B/n testing – two effective, data-driven methods of website optimization. While A/B testing pits two versions of a webpage against each other, multivariate testing expands this comparison by simultaneously testing multiple aspects of a webpage. By deploying these strategies, you can gather valuable insights and make informed decisions that significantly enhance your website’s performance.

Although A/B testing and multivariate testing aim to optimize your website, their approaches and uses can vary significantly. A/B testing, with its simplicity and straightforwardness, is perfect for minor changes and scenarios with limited resources. On the other hand, multivariate testing, with its capacity to assess a multitude of variables at once, is better suited for large-scale alterations when you have abundant traffic or resources. But which one is right for you? As we delve deeper into their pros and cons, and showcase practical examples, you’ll gain a clearer perspective on which method aligns best with your website’s needs.

Keys to A/B Testing and A/B/n Multivariate Testing

A/B testing and Multivariate A/B/n testing serve as powerful keys to unlocking your website’s full potential. Through these data-driven methodologies, you can navigate the complex terrain of website optimization, enhancing user experience while boosting conversion rates.

1) Understanding A/B Testing and A/B/n Multivariate Testing

The bedrock of effective digital optimization lies in the fundamental understanding of A/B testing and A/B/n Multivariate testing. These strategic tools offer a roadmap to better decision-making, equipping you with the knowledge to initiate and implement necessary changes. Crucially, they spotlight leading platforms that can streamline these complex procedures, making your testing journey smoother and more efficient.

What is A/B Testing and Where to Start?

A/B testing, at its core, is a way to compare two versions of a webpage to see which one yields better results. Think of it as a digital version of a classic experiment. You split your audience into two groups: one sees the original webpage (version A), and the other sees the modified webpage (version B). The performance is measured based on a predetermined metric like click-through rate, time spent on page, or conversion rate. This method’s beauty lies in its simplicity and effectiveness, making it an excellent choice for those new to the realm of website optimization.

To facilitate A/B testing, there are various tools available such as Google Optimize, Optimizely, and Visual Website Optimizer (VWO). These platforms offer intuitive interfaces, detailed analytics, and built-in statistical tools to simplify the process of running and analyzing A/B tests.

What is Multivariate A/B/n Testing and Where to Start?

Multivariate A/B/n testing takes the principles of A/B testing and supercharges them. Instead of testing one change at a time, multivariate testing allows you to test multiple changes simultaneously. This could include different headlines, images, button colors, and more. The goal here is to determine which combination of changes delivers the best results. It’s like juggling several balls at once, each representing a different website element, and finding out the best way to keep them all in the air.

tools like Google Optimize, Optimizely, and VWO can be used for multivariate testing. Additionally, Adobe Target is another comprehensive platform designed for more advanced testing and personalization requirements, making it ideal for multivariate tests. However, these tools require a good amount of traffic due to the complexity of multivariate testing.

2) Pros of Multivariate A/B/n Testing

The ability to test multiple changes at once is what sets multivariate A/B/n testing apart from its A/B counterpart. It’s akin to checking all the boxes at once instead of one at a time. The simultaneous testing not only saves you valuable time but also provides comprehensive insights into the collective impact of multiple changes on your webpage’s performance.

Multivariate testing can pinpoint the specific changes contributing the most to your conversion rate. For instance, you might discover that a combination of a specific headline and a particular image placement drives more conversions than any other variation. Such insights can guide your decision-making process, ensuring that the changes you implement are backed by hard data, not just hunches.

3) Cons of Multivariate A/B/n Testing

The power of multivariate A/B/n testing comes with its share of challenges. It necessitates a significantly larger sample size compared to A/B testing. This is due to the multiple variations being tested simultaneously, each requiring its own subset of users to gather meaningful data. This requirement can turn multivariate testing into a resource-intensive process, demanding more time and traffic than A/B testing.

The complexity of multivariate testing extends to its setup and analysis stages as well. Setting up multiple variations requires careful planning, and interpreting the results demands a solid understanding of statistical analysis. However, with the right tools and expertise, these challenges can be efficiently managed.

4) When to Use A/B Testing vs Multivariate A/B/n Testing

Deciding between A/B testing and multivariate A/B/n testing largely depends on the specifics of your situation. Here are some points to consider:

Use A/B testing when:

  • You are dealing with minor changes: A/B testing is perfect for experiments involving slight adjustments, like modifying a headline, changing a call-to-action button color, or tweaking the layout.
  • You have limited website traffic or resources: Since A/B testing involves only two versions, it requires less traffic to reach statistical significance. It’s also simpler and faster to set up, making it ideal for situations with resource constraints.
  • You’re looking to simplify decision-making: If you’re faced with multiple good ideas and need a clear winner, A/B testing can be the way to go. It can help to eliminate guesswork and build consensus within teams, which is crucial in corporate settings.

Use Multivariate A/B/n testing when:

  • You’re implementing larger changes: If your modifications span across various elements on a webpage like design overhaul, or adding new functionalities, multivariate testing can provide comprehensive insights about their combined effect.
  • You have ample website traffic and resources: To effectively run a multivariate test and achieve statistically significant results, you’ll need a larger sample size. Therefore, high website traffic or ample resources are prerequisites.
  • You want to understand interactions between variables: Multivariate tests are excellent for assessing how different webpage elements work together and influence user behavior. For instance, you might find that a certain headline works best with a specific image and call-to-action button.

Remember, the choice between A/B and multivariate A/B/n testing should align with your objectives, resources, and the nature of the changes you wish to test. Testing is a continuous process, it’s not enough to run a single test and stop. User behaviors and preferences evolve over time, and what works today might not be effective tomorrow. Therefore, make it a habit to run regular tests, measure the impact of changes, and adapt your strategies accordingly.

While testing gives us powerful insights, it’s just one part of the larger puzzle of user experience. Be sure to combine your testing efforts with other qualitative and quantitative research methods, like user interviews, heatmaps, or web analytics. This holistic approach will provide a more complete understanding of your users and help drive more effective decisions.

A Practical View of A/B Testing vs Multivariate A/B/n Testing

To illustrate the differences between A/B testing and multivariate A/B/n testing, let’s examine a couple of scenarios that a website owner or manager might face.

Scenario 1: Headline Testing

Imagine you’re running a website for a digital marketing consultancy, and you want to test the effectiveness of two different headlines on your homepage:

  • Headline A: “Unlock Growth with Our Digital Marketing Strategies”
  • Headline B: “Revolutionize Your Business with Our Digital Marketing Expertise”

In this case, A/B testing is your go-to method. You’ll present version A (with headline A) to a portion of your traffic, and version B (with headline B) to another. The headline that results in more conversions – whether that’s contact form submissions, newsletter signups, or another key performance indicator (KPI) – is the winner.

Scenario 2: Multiple Element Testing

Now, let’s suppose you’re not only interested in testing headlines but also want to assess the effectiveness of different hero images and call-to-action (CTA) button colors. You’ve got:

  • Two different headlines: A and B as mentioned above.
  • Two different hero images: Image 1 shows a team brainstorming in an office setting, and Image 2 displays an abstract graphic representation of growth.
  • Two different CTA button colors: Green (for growth and prosperity) and Blue (for trust and stability).

In this situation, you have multiple elements and various combinations to test. For instance, Headline A might work better with Image 1 and a Green CTA, while Headline B might resonate more with Image 2 and a Blue CTA.

This scenario calls for multivariate A/B/n testing, where you’re able to test all possible combinations of these variables and figure out the combination that works best for your website. This could potentially uncover correlations between variables you may not have considered and helps you optimize your site more thoroughly.

By understanding and applying A/B testing or multivariate A/B/n testing appropriately in situations like these, you can make significant strides in improving your website’s conversion rates, resulting in a better return on investment (ROI) from your digital presence.

Book a 30 minute call

Blog posts are great! But sometimes, it’s just easier to talk it out.
Reserve 30 minutes with a strategist and get 30 hours worth of value.
Book a call

Multivariate A/B/n Testing in Action

Suppose you want to test the impact of different elements on your checkout page, such as the color of the “Buy Now” button, the placement of the trust badges, and the copy on the page. In this case, you would use multivariate A/B/n testing to test all of the different combinations of changes to the checkout page to determine which combination is the most effective.

In the quest for optimal website performance, both A/B testing and multivariate A/B/n testing offer valuable insights. A/B testing is ideal for small-scale changes and when resources are limited, while multivariate testing is your go-to for assessing larger, more complex changes, especially when you have ample traffic or resources. While both methods require thoughtful implementation and analysis, their data-driven results can guide your decision-making process, empowering you to create a website that truly resonates with your audience.

Itching for more fantastic digital marketing content? Sign up for our next monthly Growth Clinic where experts share their latest secrets for excelling in B2B and B2C marketing.

Most newsletters suck...

So while we technically have to call this a daily newsletter so people know what it is, it's anything but.

You won't find any 'industry standards' or 'guru best practices' here - only the real stuff that actually moves the needle.

You may be interested in:

How to outsmart your competitors in digital marketing

How to outsmart your competitors in digital marketing

On this week’s session of The Growth Clinic, Camille Bosley (Director of Strategy at WebMechanix) shows you how to get the upper hand on your digital marketing competitors. Watch this session to get the frameworks, strategies and tactics to win....
Read this